How to look at society's underbelly

Rip-roaring reportage recommendations for those who liked "The Castle."

First up, if you aren’t already signed up to receive my fresh newsletter, Bobbie Johnson’s Faking It, please take a look—you might enjoy this exploration of the ongoing battle between authenticity and fakeness... a tale that is as old as history, but also extremely relevant in a world that’s increasingly full of baffling examples of unreality.

My elevator pitch is really that this is for anyone who has ever been fooled by an online fake or real hoax and thought “how the hell did we get here?”… because I’m trying to answer that exact question.

OK, now that’s over… let’s get stuck into a bunch of book suggestions.

I know some club members raced through our book of the month for November, Jon Ronson’s The Castle. In fact one person emailed me to say she’d finished it almost immediately! So, if you enjoyed it, where else should you look?

Here are a few recommendations I have, but if you want to suggest more then let me know.

⌘

The obvious place to start is with Ronson’s other work. Although The Castle is his first book in about a decade, it fits comfortably into his oeuvre. Them: Adventures with Extremists, which was released in 2001, reads a little quaintly now—a lot has happened in the quarter century since, and some of the characters have gone on to have arcs that weren’t easy to predict. Take the blustering Alex Jones, for example: he’s a central figure to parts of the story, and accurately portrayed… but the turn he took over the intervening years does feel a little odd on the page now.)

But it is maybe the closest to The Castle in a lot of ways, so if you want a further taste then it’s a good place to start. You can’t go wrong really, and all of his books explore similar corners of human instinct as The Castle, but I’d particularly recommend The Psychopath Test. 

⌘

Another story of men and boys out of control, Patrick Radden Keefe’s London Falling is an investigation into the mysterious death of a young man in the British capital, and one of the most talked-about books of the year.

Why? Well, the layered mysteries at the center of it are certainly intriguing. Nineteen-year-old Zac Brettler, the young victim in question, turns out to have been hoaxing his way through London by pretending to be a scion of some indeterminate Russian oligarch, and his need to appear successful in this murky otherworld leads him onto a deadly path.

I’m a huge fan of Keefe, whose books I’ve been reading since 2005’s Chatter and whose New Yorker articles I’ve been reading for at least a decade and a half. I think that London Falling is not his strongest work—I think Say Nothing and Empire of Pain are superb—but it is worth your time.

⌘

Finally, I’m going to suggest picking up Jia Tolentino’s Trick Mirror. This is a different approach, a series of essays published in 2019, but she explores a few of the same areas that Ronson hints at in his book. How technologies warp our thoughts and decisions, for example, or the weird pressures placed upon people right now by systems that chew us up and spit us out.

Her style is light and thoughtful, and she’s very funny, but interrogates herself as well as the world around her. I haven’t gone back and looked over it for a while, but it was an enjoyable read.

⌘

One thought struck me while I was going over these recommendations: I noticed how weighted the genre of reported narrative non-fiction was towards white men. It’s not a dig on any of them individually (and hey, I am a middle-aged white guy who aspires to the same genre.) There are some truly great talents in this arena.

But it also makes me wonder what stories I’m missing, and what perspectives publishers are skipping over. There are some big names who produce books that have these elements of reportage and narrative—Katherine Boo, Isabelle Wilkerson, and Ta-Nehisi Coates are some that come to mind—and I’ve tried to highlight books I’ve found interesting with previous picks like Rebecca Nagle, Karen Hao and Tania Branigan. But I’d love to see more and read more. Any suggestions?

Finally, before I sign off this week: if you’re thinking of sharing a particular book with friends or family as a holiday gift, we still have some copies to hand of various titles that you can order through our shop page.

Or you might want to try a giving a subscription to somebody as a gift—they’re very popular and will make your loved ones feel extremely smart!

Onwards

Bobbie